MUSIC IN THE MAIL - P.O. BOX ONE - BRIGHTWATERS, N.Y. 11718
TO VISITORS BUMPED HERE FROM OUR OTHER SITES, WELCOME!
This site contains our actual pre-1999 CD Reviews and WAVE soundfile archive! HAVE FUN
Clicking on the titles below will activate that soundfile. Please scroll down, if you have not already read the review.

    Starting in 1999 we switched from the wave format to streaming audio using QuickTime. The Unwanted Opinion is now an audio journal which includes web broadcasts, spoken commentary in addition to printed reviews.

CD Music Reviews Classical CD Music Reviews
Classical Music CDs Latest Releases.
Lowest CD Classical Prices Anywhere!

 

CD REVIEWS WITH SOUNDFILES ATTACHED:
Here is our list of sound files with attached reviews currently available to listen to. Each file is in the WAVE format. Sorry to say the sound of any electrical recording made after 1926 is superior to the sound on these files. Here is true 21st Century technology bringing us 19th Century fidelity!
To have a listen in genuine low-fi sound click here: Mendelssohn:Symphony #3
Hip Hop Mendelssohn Scotch
Orfeo d'Or 277 921 Argenta VSO
These 1954 recordings bear witness to a remarkable talent cut short at age 44 . Ataulfo Argenta left us a few remarkable London recordings. This Vienna Sym. concert is in absolute high fidelity. A fiercely driven Mendelssohn Sym:#3 (not without great inflection and warmth in the Adagio). The DeFalla is thrilling and really Spanish, a powerful Don Juan that ranks with Toscanini and Reiner. How I wince when I see someone ordering a Naxos recording of basic orchestral repertory (symphonies that had been recorded by great conductors). Well, I suppose that is better then buying one at full price that has been done by Ozawa or Haitink. People are confused, the Naxos seems just as good as a 90's version on full priced DG (in fact, it nearly is!). Sorry, the answer is usually found in HI-FI Mono or Early STEREO recordings. The solution has names too: Toscanini, Walter, Furtwangler, Munch, Paray, Reiner, Scherchen, Stokowski, etc., etc. * * * * *
To have a listen in genuine low-fi sound click here: Gotovac:Kolo
Testament -Testimonials
SBT 1127 On Holiday- Rudolf Kempe 79m
Splendid VPO early 60's stereos. Schmidt, Ponchielli,Offenbach,Gluck,Gounod, Bayer:Puppenfee, Schubert: Rosamunde. Saved the best for last: Gotovac:Kolo (if you love Weinberger:Polka - you will love this-- wow!) **** excellent photos & notes.
SBT 1101 Dvorak: Rostropovich and Boult.
80 minutes of earliest Rostropovich EMI stereos including the 1957 Dvorak:Cello Concerto. One of the greatest versions ever recorded. Lusty early stereo. Boult and the RPO kick up a fury. ****
SBT1109 Beethoven: Menuhin, Furtwangler Violin Concerto, Romance #1 and #2 from 1947 and 1953 EMI best sound ever. ****
SBT 1105 Homage to Diaghilev. 77 min.
Fine Igor Markevich includes:Les Sylphides (arr. Douglas), Tommasini:Good-humoured
Ladies,Dukas, deFalla,Ravel,Weber,Debussy
 

To have a listen in genuine low-fi sound click here: Halvorsen:Suite Ancienne
ANCIENT FRIEND/ NEW VERSION
HALVORSEN: SUITE ANCIENNE, op.31 and MASCARADE SUITE,+ NORWEGIAN DANCES Ari Rasilaien -Norw.Radio Orch.
NKF CD 50033 (Qualiton) * * * * *
Growing up in NY City, WQXR Radio helped form my distortedly hedonistic cultural values. They had the good taste to find rare gems in their huge record vault and regularly air them. A Halvorsen recording by Fjeldstad (even then out-of-print!) is a case in point. What a delight it is to have an new CD version of these works. Suite Ancienne
conjures up a wide array of sounds and moods.. impossible to express in words. Also, it is hard to write as this enticing music is playing, since I'd much rather just listen to it ..HAVE A NICE DAY NOW.

To have a listen in genuine Low-Fi sound click here:Berlioz: Les Troyens

WELCOME TO HERMANN SCHERCHEN FAN CLUB
If ever asked to rattle off a list of my top 10 conductors, I sound nearly sane for the first two or three names (Toscanini, Furtwanger etc.)...then I say Hermann Scherchen and we sometimes get that strange look. Happy to report, we now sell Tahra Records- distributed by Jem Music.
Tahra is currently the finest and most active CD label devoted to unearthing performances by many of the great conductors of the past. It is run by Myrian Scherchen (his daughter) so Hermann Scherchen recordings get a major emphasis.Many of these performances
are live concerts or broadcasts, some stereo. Sound is always good or very good.
While not always having the advantage of the fine demonstration quality hi-fi and stereo sound this great conductor had on many of his commercial Westminster LPs, these CDs are nearly as wonderful. Many Tahra items are the first Scherchen performances in any recorded format.
Let me list the Tahra recordings of Scherchen currently issued:

TAH 185/189 (5 CD SET FOR THE PRICE OF JUST 3 CDs!)
A Tribute to Hermann Scherchen- "The BEST-KNOWN UNKNOWN"
Bach:Musical Offering 1950 Vienna; Beethoven:Sym#9 #8 Stereo 1965 Lugano rehearsal/performance; Berlioz:Les Troyens Ballet '52 Paris; Verdi:Nabucco Ovt Prokofiev:Lt Kije SW Radio 1962;
Kalinnikov:Sym#1 1950 Czech Phil
Bach/Schoenberg:Prel
Schoenberg Sym#1, op.9,Krenek: Sym#1 1955 Swiss Radio; Schoenberg:La Danse autour du Veau d'Or Darmstadt 1951; Bartok:
Music Perc.Sts,Celesta 1954 Swiss
TAH 147 MAHLER (4 CD SET FOR PRICE OF JUST 2 CDs!) Sym #6; Sym#3; Sym#10 Leipzig
1960; Sym #8 first mvt. Berlin State 1951; plus Kindertotenlieder
Cervena, alto Leipzig 1960
TAH 120 MAHLER:Sym#8 1951 Vienna Fest. Anday,Wiener,Majkut
TAH 103 MusicVol 1 Leipzig'60
Schumann:Manfred; Beethoven:Prometheus
TAH 104 MusicVol 2'60Leipzig
Mendelssohn:Midsummer Nights Dream; Grieg:Peer Gynt
TAH 105 MusicVol. 3'60Leipzig
Beethoven:Egmont; Bizet:L'Arlesienne
TAH 108/09 Bach:Art of the Fugue Stereo
includes rehearsals Toronto Dec.1965
TAH 112 Tchaikovsky:Sym#6; Wagner:Sieg fried Idyll (chamber version) NW Ger.Phil '60
TAH 113 Mozart:Les Petits Riens, Ser. #13;
Con. FluteVienna St. Orch 1940's
TAH 116 SCHERCHEN AT LUGANO '62
Dvorak:Cello Con (Fournier); Brahms:Sym#3
TAH 126/128 SCHERCHEN CONDUCTS BEETHOVEN: (mono&stereo) Sym#1, #2; Ruins of Athens; Consecration of the House; Egmont; An die Hoffnung; Grosse Fugue (rehearsal performance); Wellington's Victory (rehearsal performance)Lugano '65;
Leipzig 1960; SW Radio 1962; Toronto '65

Berlioz Review: * * * * *
TAH 143/44 Berlioz: Les Troyens a Carthage Paris '52 Giraudeau,Collard,Depraz,Mandikian
Scherchen ranks with Toscanini and Munch (Paray, Monteux, Beecham etc.) as the finest Berlioz conductor within the last 50 years. This magnificent sounding Hi-Fidelity
version of Berlioz: Les Troyens a Carthage makes any other version seem stillborn. If you want to give Scherchen a fair try, start here. Tap into the Frenchest sounding (played
and sung) Berlioz you may ever hear !
If you don't like this performance, I can eat your returned CDs at no additional charge. (Mind you, you won't get your money back- I may simply eat your returned copy of the Berlioz with my morning milk and corn flakes.)


Other interesting TAHRA sets:
THE ART OF HANS KNAPPERTSBUSCH TAH 132/135 NDR Sym. Direct from NDR Archive masters. Bruckner:Sym#3; all-Wagner Concert with Christa Ludwig; Beethoven: Coriolan Ovt; Piano Con#5 (Andor Foldes) and Sym:#8 (not just any Beethoven: Sym#8 - but the slowest, broadest, weirdest and most demented in the ENTIRE universe - - - - and one you should not be without!)

PIERRE MONTEUX IN AMSTERDAM
TAH 175/178 Berlioz:Sym.Fantast; Brahms: Tragic Ovt ,Sym#1 #3;Vio.Con(Milstein); Sibelius: Violin Con (Damen);and Stravinsky:Petrouchka

To have a listen in genuine low-fi sound click here:VINCENT SYMPHONY IN D
MORE POWER TO US ***** Troy 250 (albany) Eugene Ormandy - Philadelphia Orch.
Dello Joio: Air Power Suite; John Vincent: Symphony in D and Sym. Poem after Descartes. (76 minutes)
Ask me if I am happy about this new CD and I will tell you I am Dello Joio! These are two of the finest Ormandy Stereo Columbias. My heart sank when Koch released a CD of 'Air Power', wretched DDD sound of a rotten performance. Treasure that well played Ormandy LP, forever, I thought.
A few decades ago a number of contemporary composers like Dello Joio and Vincent held out a glimmer of hope that it was not over for truly fine, original and endemic American music....it was, but who cares now. "Don't lets ask for the the moon! We have the stars!" (Bette Davis, 'Now Voyager'). The Vincent Symphony ranks next to those of Roy Harris, as worthy of your attention. The finale is a jump for joy! * * * * *
 
To have a listen in genuine low-fi sound click here: Chabrier:Marche Joyeuse
BARBIROLLI LIVING PRESENCE
CDSJB 1006 BARBIROLLI- Halle Favourites Some items never before released, most are in wall-to-wall early Mercury STEREO - some items even engineered by the Mercury 'Living Presence' team. The 71 min CD begins with a a tightly played Verdi: Forza del Destino from 1957, which is among the finest you may ever hear. Mascagni: Cavalleria Rusticana Intermezzo, an impassioned 1958 recording which features a 'very prominent' (woofer moving) Free Trade Hall, Manchester organ!
Next, is the best stereo version of Ponchielli: Dance of the Hours ever recorded. From the twinkling opening chord to the zippy.. go for it finale (only Toscanini is better)... hold on tight! The Chabrier: Marche Joyeuse is a bang upside the head, hip hopping spotlight on the Percussion section of the Halle. The 1957 German:Nell Gwyn Dances with Barbirolli - are a rare treat. Grainger: Shepherd's Hey, Molly on the Shore, Londonderry Air, Mock Morris put other versions to shame. We even get Sir John in a Stereo rehearsal of Shepherd's Hey! Massenet:Under the Linden Tree is elegant and I have saved the best Stereo till last: Rossini : William Tell the ballet music..... 14 minutes of pure joy, from the graceful high-stepping opening, to a decibel crunching Dance of the Soldiers. (Nearly matches the intensity of the legendary 1939 NBC broadcast version with Toscanini) Remember, No Extra Charge for Sir John humming loudly at times. A Classic 'Living Presence' Stereo must *****
Over the past year or so, many wonderful items honoring Sir John Barbirolli have come out on the Dutton Label. The most recent CD called BARBIROLLI - Halle Favorites is so great we have to make a pitch for it and recap the other noteworthy past releases:
DUTTON (thru Allegro imports):
CDEA5000 NY PHIL. The 1938/39 RCA recordings: Tchaikovsky:Francesca; Schubert: Sym #4; Debussy:Iberia (70 min)
CDSJB 1001 BARBIROLLI IN NEW YORK
1938 New York Philharmonic all Wagner Concert: Rienzi; Tannhauser:Venusberg; Die Meistersinger Suite; Siegfried Idyll (76 min.) CJSJB 1002 BARBIROLLI CONDUCTS FRENCH MUSIC 1950-54 HMVs (76 min.)
L'Arlesienne; Faure:Pelleas; Ibert: Divertiss.; Saint-Saens: Carnival of Animals; Debussy.
CDSJB 1003 HAYDN: Sym #83, #96, #88 with Halle Orch.: 1949/1953/1952 recordings
CDSJB 1004 BARBIROLLI At The OPERA Strauss:Liebe der Danae and Rosenkavalier Suites; Weber: Freischutz and Euryanthe Ovt. Verdi:Traviata Preludes, Lohengrin Preludes.
CDSJB 1005 BARBIROLLI conducts Delius: A Song of Summer (and all the stereo Pyes).
 
To have a listen in genuine low-fi sound click here: Dvorak: ARMIDA (2cd set)
ARMIDA ---- DVORAK'S LAST OPERA, AT LAST!
ORFEO C 404 962 Gerd Albrecht cond 1995
DVORAK:ARMIDA Live with Czech Philharmonic soloists: Daniluk, Borowska, Fortune, Kriz (152 min)
Here it is at last, the first stereo recording of the 1904 Dvorak opera 'Armida'. Set during the Crusades in the Holy Land, this one is full of pomp, spectacle, battle, religious fervor, love, magic and mysticism. Pitted between the forces of Allah and Christianity is a women from the East, in love with a man from the West. Among the grandest of grand opera. The plot 'bang for the buck' factor is quite high here. Paging Mr. DeMille, the soundstage is ready....and load the other cannon. Really Excellent ****
To have a listen in genuine low-fi sound click here:Dvorak: St.Ludmila 112141 (2cd)
CZECH IT OUT
Let this be our own Prague Spring Music Festival, as we do some catch up to note some of the
many worthwhile releases from the Supraphon label. (KOCH Distributes this label)
Czech Operas & Oratorios:
Dvorak: St.Ludmila
112141 (2cd) *****
Dvorak: Devil & Kate
11 1800 (2cd) ****
Dvorak: Dimitrij
11 1259 (3cd) ***
Dvorak: Cunning Peasant
SU 0019 (2cd) ***
Dvorak: Rusalka
SU 0013 (2cd)****
Dvorak:Jacobin
11 2190 (2cd)****
Dvorak:Specter's Bride & Novak: The Storm '61&'56 perf. 111982 (2cd)***
Smetana: The Kiss
11 2180 (2cd)***
Smetana: Devil's Wall
11 2201*** (2cd)
Smetana:Dalibor
11 2185 (2cd)****
Smetana:Brandenburgers in Bohemia (2cd)****
Smetana:Bartered Bride
SU 0040 2cd ****
Fibich:Bride of Messina
11 1492 2cd ***
Blodek(1834-74):In the Well
SU 0033 (1CD) ****

First mention goes to Dvorak:St. Ludmilla, it is the only ***** ( highest recommendation ) item in this section. Doubt this fine work will fail give you great pleasure. The St. Ludmila oratorio is one of
the best works that Dvorak wrote. This performance from 1963, conducted by Vaclav Smetacek
and the Czech Phil. is imbued with religious inspiration and pure joy. It typifies the type of highly
idiomatic Czech singing and orchestral playing that appears to be lost as we approach the 21st
Century. Stereo is wall-to-wall with close up miking on top brass and tight drums when needed
(alas- some vocal solos are a bit close in for my taste). GRAB IT! *****



Smetana: Bartered Bride and Dvorak: Russalka are perhaps the two best known Czech operas.
Both performances are conducted by Zdenek Chalabala (the Toscanini of Czech Opera!) with the
Prague National Theatre. These stereo recordings from the early 1960's capture that long lost
feeling of an authentic Czech performing tradition.
Compare either with the newer DDD Czech versions and the point is made. The singing has heart
and you really get to believe in the wonder of these folk tales. The playing time is 132 min and
149 min respectively - each opera is tightly squeezed on 2 CD sets and are mid-priced.. What more do you want!


Smetana:Devil's Wall 137 min on 2CDs is also a Chalabala performance with many of the same
1960's Prague Theatre soloists: Ivo Zidek, Vaclav Bednar, Milada Subrtova (who was Rusalka &
Hedvika in Devil's Wall).
Devil's Wall is a "Comic Romantic" opera from 1882. It is a romantic tale with a happy ending (buthardly a ha-ha comedy). Set in the 13th Century,
a tale of love found at last, between a secludedcountess and an older man.


Smetana:Brandenburgers in Bohemia is a 1963 performance (149 min on 2 CD's) of the first opera by Smetana. Written in 1862 it is heroic in scope and subject. It concludes with a magnificentchorus in praise of freedom:"Long live truth.. Long live our Rights!"
It opened a new epoch inCzech national music and remains one of the movements
crowning achievements. First rate sound & performance.


Similar in scale is Dalibor a tragic opera in 3 Acts. It was revised in 1870. Smetana again deals
with the story of an oppressed people and the heroic life of a man sentenced to death by feudal
powers in 1498. Powerful music to stir the blood and send goosebumps down your spine!
Excellent sound from this 1967 studio recording conducted by Jaroslav Krombholc and the PragueNational Theatre. 145 min on 2 CD.


The Kiss was written by Smetana during the end of his career and premiered in 1876 when the
composer was completely deaf. It was a great success. The plot centers around the power of love
to overcome every obstacle. It is filled with wonderful things: several great duets & arias, fun filleddances and choruses etc. The performance is from 1980 in Brno.
Frantisek Vajnar conducts a cast
including: Eduard Haken, Eva Depoltova and Leo Vodicka. 2CD 113 min. Most enjoyable.
The Vilem Blodek (1834-1874) comic opera in 1 Act The Well, proved to be a delight. His style
sounds a bit like that of Flotow in Martha. Great overture, lively chorus and memorable tunes.Jan
Stych cond Prague NationalTheatre. 1 CD 67 min. Discover!


Dvorak: Jacobin was written in 1888 and revised again in 1898.
The opera features many important choral items (church scenes & cantatas), some dance sections
and heartfelt solos. Especially fine bass and soprano parts. The plot is about the alienation between
father and son with a final blessing by dad to his sons new bride. A 1994 recording on 2 CD. Jiri
Pinkas conducts Brno State. 155 min.


Kate and the Devil by Dvorak was premiered in 1899, the magnificent overture which is the best
known part of the opera was written last. The opera has much appeal because of its combination of
fairy tale and folk music, it is as close in feel to a Czech tone poem as an opera can be. At times, it
feels like a Czech version of Hansel & Gretel. What a really sweet treat this work is. Jiri Pinkas
conducts Brno Opera. This 1980 recording is on 2 CD -118 min. Great AAD sound. Leap!
Dvorak:The Cunning Peasant a 1986 Prague Radio- Frantisek Vajnar features Vaclav Zitek & Eva Depoltova.
This 1877,2 Act comic opera was a great success. It helped establishthe rising popularity of Czech Opera throughout the Austrian Empire and Germany.
Some critics did not understand the emerging trend.
Edward Hanslick believed the opera exhibited a "heavysymphonic style" and thought the ballet in the second actwas more like the Scherzo of a Dvorak symphony.
In retrospect, this sounds like two good reasons to want this opera! (120min) ***


Dvorak:The Specter's Bride & Fibich:The Storm are two cantatas ably performed by the Czech
Phil. Under Jaroslav Krombholc (2CD mid-price 155 min). The Dvorak is 1961 Stereo, Novak is
1956 Mono. Somber works.


Dimitrij is a Czech Boris Godunov. First performed in 1882 the work was revised at least twice.
Originally, a 5 act libretto, the work was changed by Dvorak to emphasize the simultaneity of the
operas contemplative moments in (ensembles and solos) and to contrast them with the collective
drama elements (the Russian peoples choruses acting and reflecting these events independently).
This is a 1989 Prague Radio performance conducted by Gerd Albrecht. No "Boris ", but interesting.
( 3CD set 191 min.) ***


The Bride of Messina by Fibich sounds like a heroic Czech opera written in a style more akin to
Massenet then Dvorak. A Tragic Opera in 3 Acts it was first performed in 1884. Frantisek Jilek
conducts this fine sounding 1975 Prague Radio recording. (2 CD 136 min.) ***



CZECH SYMPHONIC WORKS:

Smetana:Wallenstein's Camp, Richard III, Hakon Jarl; Dvorak:In Nature's Realm, Scherzo
Capriccioso - 70 min
Karel Sejna-Czech Phil. SU 1915 *** (mono '58)
Smetana:Festive Sym, op6; Festive Ovt. Op 4; Dvorak:
Cunning Peasant; Skroup: The Tinker Ovt. - 69 min **** Karel Sejna-Czech Phil.
SU 1914 (Stereo/Mono)
Suk:Summer Tale, Meditation on Czech Chorale; Dvorak: Husitska.
SU 1923 *** mono
Karel Sejna-Czech Phil.-73 min

Novak:In the Tatras, Eternal Longing; Fibich:Water Goblin, & Christmas Day
Karel Sejna-Czech Phil. - 68 min. SU 1922 (Stereo/ Fibich is Mono) ***
Dvorak: 10 Legends, Sym. Var. ***
Karel Sejna- Czech Phil - 64 min. (Mono)

Postage stamp covers, postage stamp size reviews of these mid-price historic releases under the
noted conductor Karel Sejna, who with Talich seemed to be the cat's whiskers of Czech
symphonic conducting. The Smetana tone poems were the first available on LP and have much to
offer in authenticity, drive and insight. The fine Stereo sound in the Smetana Festive Symphony
offers a wide soundstage to this vigorous **** performance. The Dvorak Legends get just the righta loving, warm touch. In the case of the Fibich ***, this is the only available version of this
unusual format of narrated musical melodramas.


Vranicky:Sym.D Op.52; c (no opus) 11 0956 56 min DDD
Vranicky: Sym D op. 36, C op. 11
11 1332 57 min DDD
B. Gregor cond. Dvorak Chamber Orch Delightful big-boned classical works
(scored similar to the later Haydn syms) of Pavel Vranicky (1756-1807). First rate music by the #1Czech classical era symphonist - highly infectious stuff - pure joy!
Nice close bright sound. ****


Ostrcil: Sym A,op.7 & Sinfonietta
11 1826 78 min. Belohlavek-Prague
Tell your friends you found a lost Dvorak symphony, they may believe you. Otkar Ostrcil wrote
this sunny romantic work in 1904 when he was 25. After the first movement, look down to see
how many clouds you are walking on! ****

Martinu: Butterfly that Stamped
11 0380 42 min Belohlavek-Prague
One of the oddest and best works by this prolific composer. A strangely magical ballet with a
chanting wordless chorus. Based on a 5 part Kipling story, this 1926 Paris premiere was an early
success for Martinu. Sounds like The Rite of Spring meets Daphnis on Fog Island with King Kongand Max Steiner not too far away. Enjoy. ****

Fibich:Comenius (Festive Ovt.), Zaboj, Slavoj & Ludfek (Sym poem), Toman and
the Wood Nymph, The Fall of Arkona Ovt.11 1823 54 min V. Valkek-Prague
If you are like me, it is hard to put your finger on the Fibich style. You might think parts of the
Comenius Ovt. were written by Elgar! In any case if you like late Brahms, mid-period Wagner or
Smetana heroics - Fibich is your cup of tea. These are some of his most dramatic and accessible
works. DDD recording is a bit tubby&dark ***
TALICH IN STEREO (ALMOST)SUPRAPHON 3056-2 011 ****
Czech Philharmonic with Zdenek Chalabala 80min
Yes, the 4 tone poems one 80 minute CD.
Dvorak Water Goblin , The Noon Witch , The Golden Spinning Wheel, The Wild Dove. These excellent 1961 Stereo performances capture the magic of the Czech Philharmonic at the peak (they could turn on a dime!). Wit, style, tight playing, painted with an authentic Slavic brush. Supplement this CD with the needed Heroic Song on Naxos (8.553005) and you have your cycle. (You can get the real Talich, in mono on - Supraraphon 11 1900)
To have a listen in genuine low-fi sound click here:GRETRY: CARAVANE DU CAIRE
RICERCAR RICHES GRETRY: LE CARAVANE DU CAIRE
MARC MINKOWSKI c.-WDR coproduction
Jules Bastin, Greta de Reyghere etc.
Opera Ballet in 3 Acts. (2 CD) 120min
Ricercar RIC100084/085
A real "Turkish" delight - one of the most extroverted classical works you may ever hear. It was
the rage of Paris in 1783. The percussion in the overture alone might wake the dead and test your
system too. To quote:"A Masterpiece... Gretry's talent lay in his ability to fuse these
brightly-coloured elements together with music that was perfect in its aptness for the opera-ballet
genre, a style with a glorious past but still little known." Fine"live" performance ****
(Qualiton distributes)
FINE GRAUN SIRLOIN
GRAUN: CLEOPATRA & CAESAR
RENE JACOBS c.Concerto Koln(3 hr.18m)
Harmonia Mundi 901561/63 HM
Janet Williams, Iris Vermillion (3cd set)
Includes:Free #4 CD featuring Jacobs.****
One of the most consistently enjoyable baroque operas ever recorded. Highly engaging - aria after
aria, chorus after chorus - painlessly short recitatives that don't bog down the flow of the musical
drama. Graun has spectacle,pomp, power - played and sung with great conviction. Crisp, clean, up-front orchestral balance
To have a listen in genuine Low Fi sound click here:Beethoven Sym #5 Stokowski 1941
MONO MADNESS------
MUSIC&ARTS 857 STOKOWSKI All-American Orch.1940-41 (74min)
This disc contains two unforgettable performances-Beethoven:Sym#5 and Brahms:Sym:#1. The Fifth opens with the slowest and most powerful first movement "fate" theme ever heard! Fate isn't knocking at the door, it is being kicked in! This performance puts into perspective the romantic mystique surrounding this symphony and captures like no other performance ever will, the fervor of the time -1941 - as we summon the most resounding V for VICTORY ever heard. Brass seems doubled and there are many Stokowskian orchestral "touch ups". The Brahms First concludes this disc in an equally unique and fitting way. Orchestral textures becomes organ like and we seem to ascend into some cathedral beyond the clouds.. Sound is astonishingly hi-fi! You will be playing and talking about this disc till the day fate knocks at your door and you ascend to heaven! A MUST BUY *****

MUSIC & ARTS 845 STOKOWSKI
LEOPOLD STOKOWSKIAll-American Youth Orchestra 1940/41
Brahms:Sym#4, Bach, Mendelssohn: Scherzo, Strauss:Death & Transfiguration. Another great Hi-Fi sounding CD with the AAYO! This impassioned recording of Bach/Stokowski:Andante Sostenuto is the only version that Stoky recorded.
The Brahms and Strauss are a tribute to a lost tradition of conducting. The triumph of style over notation, in the true romantic tradition. ***

Stoky CALA Gala CALA 0502 (Allegro Imports)
La Marseillaise, Saltarello, Balance Test March, Oh Susannah, Dance of 7 Veils, Adirondack Suite, Tyrolean Dances, March Slav, Romeo&Juliet, Scriabin, Messiah etc.
Includes a l935 Philadelphia Gala in Hi-Fi!! Stokowski shares a wicked sense of humor with his audience, taking pot shots at music critics, his board of trustees, and "serious" music appreciation. I quickly found myself "attending"this concert, laughing with the audience and amazed by the sound of this CD. Provides true Stoky insights. ****
STOKY STOKY
CALA 0506 Stokowski Hollywood Bowl NYC Tchaikovsky:Sym#6; Strauss: Death&Transf.
Fine performances you might consider ***
CALA 0505 Stokowski Russian Masterworks
Russ.Easter Ovt;Tchaikovsky:Humoresque.; Firebird Suite; Love 3 Oranges March; and Tchaikovsky: Sym#4 NBC Sym 1942 performances.
Highlights include the vocal bass soloist in the Russian Easter Overture (N.Moscona).
Very, very nice NBC playing (as usual).
Both CD issues have good clean sound ****
To have a listen in genuine Low-Fi sound click here:Handel:Judas MacCabaeus
TOP JUDAS ***** HARMONIA MUNDI 907077.78 (2 CD set)
CD#1 - 78 min CD#2 - 79 min HANDEL: JUDAS MACCABAEUS
NICHOLAS McGEGAN- Philharmonia Baroque Orch. UC Berkeley Chorus
Being a Handel Oratorio nut and especially of Judas MacCabaeus which is the near equal of Messiah, we publish this slightly belated review. The usual preference is for UK forces doing Handel (the King serieson Hyperion is quite good), here is an exceptional exception to the rule.The King version only begins to pick up steamabout half way through the performance.
The HM version under McGegan takes command from the opening chord, holds and builds throughout the entire work. Some of the earlier McGegan HM's were a bit on the underwhelming side- weak string playing, poor intonation from the chorus and fairly edgy digital sound. Things have apparently gotten better over the last several years.
A bit of background, many of the earlier stereo versions (most issued on LP) are performed with modern forces and don't seem able to negotiate the orchestral passages with the needed dexterity. Some of the older singers (Peerce,Young etc.) are great but need the proper style & spirit from the orchestral accompaniment.The Mackerras Archiv seemed the best of the lot. Each of these versions were cut!. So here I thought I had it as good as it could be with the Hyperion and HM sends me a sampler CD of the McGegan.... OH BOY! McGegan gets more enthusiasm from his forces,crisp and energized brass, very sharp percussion, greatly improved string tone (OK not 100%), excited and involved singers who get better with every listen. Sound is excellent.
Best of all, look at the running time of these CD's- nearly 80 min. each disc-
McGegan has an Appendix on the second disc which contains 8 tracks of additional alternate sections of Judas.
Highest Recommendation *****
MORE IF YOU CAN YOU HANDLE ADDITIONAL HANDEL!
HANDEL:OCCASIONAL ORATORIO CDA 66961/2 (2CD) . FIRST RECORDING!
For me the occasion lasted nearly a week- I could not stop playing this!
Written in 1746 to raise flagging spirits in London (the Army of George II was doing battle against Prince Charles for the English throne). This may be the most exciting oratorio ever written. The work is not entirely original-Handel took from other works including a rousing version of Zadok the Priest.This is the Handel of war (trumpets & drums ablaze),hope, faith, joy,
inspiration and redemption.*****
BRETHREN GATHER, HEAR ME
Hyperion CDA 67171/3 Handel: Joseph and His Brethren Robert King conducts Kenny, Bowman, Kings Consort, Oxford Choir.
This one got stuck in the CD player and would not come out! 'Joseph' Ranks with the very finest of the Handel oratorios. This is very mature Handel 1744 and there are several numbers (especially the choruses) that you may find the BEST Handel ever wrote. Jump on this item! 165 minutes of music that makes life worth living...who the hell wants to read about this, when we can listen it.. Guess what, it just got stuck in my CD player AGAIN! ...see ya! ****
WATER MUSIC WITH CHORUS
CPO 999 373 (2cd set) Telemann: Hamburg Admiralty Music; Ovt. In C (120 min)
Helbich - Bremen Orch, Choir and Soloists.
Move over Handel, Telemann is coming! Not only is he bringing a festive orchestra to celebrate the waters but a chorus and soloists!OK, well nobody handles Handel, like Handel handles Handel but Telemann isn't far away.
Written to celebrate the Admiralty in 1723, this is a festive and patriotic occasional work. Many great solos, choruses and instrumental selections. Fairly lively stuff complete with brass and drums. The Cd was recorded a bit low and the performance is very good but hardly driven. Crank the volume control and live it up. * * * *
To have a listen in genuine Low-Fi sound click here:Festival Overture on the Rhine Wine
WACKO SCHUMANN (QUALITON) EBS 6033 (3 CD SET)
Is it true?: a) Florian Merz is the illegitimate son of Hans Knappertsbusch. b) Florian Merz ran in lead shoes for over six months before recording this Schumann cycle. c) recorded timpani can sound likeTNT detonations. - (the correct answer is C and possibly B! )
EBS 6088 (3 CD set)
Schumann: The Orchestral Works- Florian Merz and the Dusseldorf Philharmonie.
When this set came out about 2 years ago, I took great delight in playing it for friend to see the shocked expression on their faces. After it was over, the same response - get me a copy on the next Qualiton order!Works include the untouched original instrumentation of all 4 symphonies (not an easy listen for the faint of heart!), Overtures to Julius Caesar, Manfred, Bride of Messina and (don't laugh)the first recording of Song for soloists, chorus and orchestra! a fine work: the Festival Overture on the Rhine Wine. Talk about getting drunk on music, this work is akin to the great Beethoven:Choral Fantasy.

"There's been a drumming and trumpeting within in me for a few days now (trumpets in C)", wrote Schumann to Felix Mendelssohn in September 1845, " I don't yet know
what it will bring?" Perhaps Florian Merz does. A Must Hear CD *****

MORE FLORIAN MERZ SCHUMANN NEW RELEASE - LIVE RECORDING:
EBS 6091 SW Philharmonie -Florian Merz
Overture, Scherzo & Finale and premiere recording of the 1841 version of the Sym. #4 arranged by Johannes Brahms and Franz Wullner. The CD liner notes state that Merz received his diploma in music from Adolf Holler - was this a misprint? Everyone should appreciate an attempt at a new insight into classic works or a unique interpretive vision...no matter no matter how deviant.
A must hear! *****
To Have a listen in genuine Low Fi sound click here:Marco Polo 8.223608 Gunga Din.

HISTORICAL ROMANCES Marco Polo 8.223608
Good grief!... I never thought I would take this one out of my CD player. Works include: Korngold: Juarez Overture and Devotion, Steiner: The Charge of the Light Brigade, and Alfred Newman: Gunga Din. The first CD of the score to one of the greatest films ever made! As a film professor, one of my joys is running the film society at the college..I had scheduled Gunga Din and this CD came just 2 weeks before our screening..IT SURE OPENED MY EARS!. Many of us know this score...but we may never really hear how dramatic, moving or memorable it is, till we experience it on this CD!
Richard Kaufman conducts the Brandenburg Philharmonic. *****
 

CAPTAIN BLOOD Marco Polo 8.223607
Enough Swash to Buckle you! Orchestral Suites from the films: The King's Thief by Miklos Rozsa, Scaramouche by Victor Young, The 3 Musketeers by Max Steiner &Erich Wolfgang Korngold-Captain Blood. Richard Kaufman conducts the Brandenburg Philharmonic in a very juicy recording. Sonic satisfaction to match your wildest Hollywood Studio System Era dreams.****
RADIANT ROZSA ****KOCH 3-7379-2 Miklos Rozsa : ViolinConcerto, op.24 ; Con. For String Orch, Andante For Strings.
Gruppman, Sedares - New Zealand Sym. This 31 minute Violin Concerto is near the top of a very
short list of the best violin concertos written within the last 50 years. Koch has apparently cleaned up its DDD act and the sound is now fairly warm with a solid bottom. Well played. This is volume 4 of the Rozsa series, get the hint! Great stuff.
To have a listen in genuine low fi sound click here: Alfred Newman:Prince of Foxes
HITTING THE HEIGHTS A TRIBUTE to Alfred NEWMAN
Koch 373762 (57 min) New Zeland Sym & Choir - Richard Kaufman
A demo quality sounding CD (Is it really Koch ???). If you were only buying one CD this month, this should be it! Six suites from great films. The disc begins with the deep, soul stirring 'Wuthering Heights' suite with choir. 'Brigham Young' is nearly a mini tone poem done with a panache John Williams could never attain! Newman pulls it off, with one hand tied behind his back! The rich, darkly textured score'Dragonwyck' is contrasted with the Straussian eroticism of 'David and Bathsheba. ''Rhapsody for Orchestra'based on the film 'Prisoner Of Zenda' is a heroic triumph not unlike the famed Newman score to 'Captain from Castile'. Saving the best till last, is the suite from the film 'Prince of Foxes'. This may be the finest score of Alfred Newman! Filled with drama, tension and passion, amid the evocative theme of Renaissance Italy. Highly authoritative notes and photos by Tony Thomas.The conductor, Richard Kaufman has captured the spirit of Newman better than anyone has in the last three decades.*****
To have a listen in genuine low fi sound click here: Hans J. Salter Wichita Town
ADVENTURES in Hollywood CITADEL STC 77108 (ALBANY)
Hans J. Salter: Wichita Town
Tiomkin: A President's Country
Farnon:Captain Horatio Hornblower
This CD has quite possibly the most quintessentially Western film score ever composed on it....Hans J. Salter: Wichita Town. Who knew! If you told me that I would be singing high praise for, Hans J. Salter, I might have told you to stuff it south of the border. This score, all 16 cuts were recorded in Munich by the Graunke Symphony under the direction of the composer in 1959. This is vintage demonstration quality early stereo! Any fan of 'Living Stereo' will buy the CD for the sonics alone! Transfer is 20 bit audiophile stereo ADD. Music so 'Old West' in nature, it almost seems as if the score to 'High Noon' depicts the streets of Philadelphia! Speaking of the great Russian, Mr. Dimitri Tiomkin, 'A Presidents Country' is a Film Score for a documentary about LBJ and contains music from 'Red River,' 'The Alamo', 'Duel in the Sun', 'Rawhide' and yes, his great 'High Noon'!
**** and SMILE when you say that Pardner !
ANOTHER BAR, ANOTHER BELLY
KOCH 7365 Kaufman - New Zealand Sym.
SHANE A TRIBUTE TO VICTOR YOUNG
This new CD contains suites from 6 classic films scored by Victor Young: Shane (14 min) For Whom the Bell Tolls (9 min), Samson and Delilah (12 min), Tribute to Victor Young - Suite (9 min), The Quiet Man (9 min) and the epilogue to Around the World in 80 Days (7 min) This Victor Young disc presents a number seldom heard items. The 'Shane' Suite is glorious, as is the'Victor Young Tribute' and both are CD firsts ***
 
PETER & THE THEREMIN
ROZSA: THE JUNGLE BOOK (also SPELLBOUND Score) 67 min.
Pearl CD 7093 Sabu, composer and the Victor Symphony Orch.
Original 1942 and 1945 studio recordings.
Narrated by Sabu from the score to the 'Jungle Book', Rosza has given the world another 'Carnival of the Animals', or 'Peter and the Wolf'. A perfect way to introduce young and old to the delights of musical tales and leitmotifs. (28 min).
This CD also contains nearly all of the highly original music composed in 1945 by Rozsa (40 minutes worth) for the classic Alfred Hitchcock film: 'Spellbound'. Theremin enthusiasts rejoice, this is the real thing! ***
 
East/West STEINER BEST
STEINER: The Lost Patrol, Virginia City, Beast with Five Fingers (77 min) MarcoPolo 8.223870 William Stromberg-conducts the Moscow Sym. Orch.
Another great entry in the Marco Polo film score series. Three Max Steiner films which encompass widely disparate yet, quintessential Steiner styles. I grew up watching John Ford's 1934 RKO film 'The Lost Patrol' in a Saturday morning 'kids TV' slot. I knew not who John Ford nor Max Steiner were, I only knew this was a highly compelling film which filled a young mind with rich images and exciting sounds. Steiner contrasts patriotic 'stiff upper lip' king
and country vs. arabic 'eastern' modes filled with rich exoticness. Next, off to sunny Italy filled with Tarantellas, a mysterious Chaconne and some ghastly, near atonal dissonances. This is 'The Beast with 5 Fingers,' a horror film about a classical pianist's living severed hand. The last film is the massive Civil War era Warners western 'Virgina City'. A big, bold adventure that allowed ample room for majestic and lilting themes for stunning landscapes, gunbattles, barroom action, stagecoaches and romance. This is one the better known Steiner idioms - a Warner Brothers western score (he did over twenty!) and is among his very best. A Great sounding CD ****
DIGGING FOR KORN-GOLD (62min)
M. Polo 8.223871 Stromberg-Moscow Sym
Korngold: Another Dawn, Escape Me Never
The 1937 score is the least ambitious Korngold every wrote, a large part of the problem is the orchestra not knowing style. A) Fine sound. B) No other version ever! C) Korngold loyalty. EQUALS *** rating.

To have a listen in genuine low fi sound click here:Siegfried Wagner CPO999-366-2
CLASSICAL NATIONAL ENQUIRER .PAGE - "IF WE PRINT IT MUST BE TRUE":

SON OF DVORAK
Classical National Enquirer headline:
"Siegfried Wagner Actually Fathered by Antonin Dvorak .. Humperdinck Jealous! " Well, judging by these selections it might be true!
CPO 999 377-2 Volume 3
CPO 999 378-2 Volume 4
CPO 999 366-2 Symphonic Poems
Here are the next three installments in the complete overtures and tone poems of Siegfried Wagner on CPO.Only 3 of the greatest CDs ever issued - thats all.
"If you only going to try one unfamiliar romantic composer this year.. let it be Siegfried Wagner ".. 3 thumbs up! Siskel Ibert - (Jacques little brother turned idiot movie critic). This stuff shimmers, it glows, it is heaven come to earth... glory, bliss, magic in the form of MUSIC... Absolute complete contentment, walking on clouds, joy beyond belief. SIX Stars! (sorry, we only allow 5) * * * * *W.A. Albert cond. Rheinland Hamburg Phil. Excellent sound.

MORE CPO -----SON OF WAGNER

CPO 999 003 Vol 1. Siegfried Wagner
CPO 999 300 Vol. 2 Siegfried Wagner
Rheinland Philharmonic- W.A. Albert cond.
Delightful Overtures, Preludes& Orchestral Interludes, many in their first recordings.
Simply marvelous music, most exceedingly joyous in spirit and filled with wonder and
fantasy - a user friendly mix of his dad, Dvorak and Rimsky-Korsakov! Nice clean sound. ****
(Naxos now Distributes CPO)


WAGNERIAN REVENGE!
Classical National Enquirer headline:
"Wagner Asserts...Siegfried Is My Son..... Offers Proof " :
ORFEO C312 941A (Qualiton)
K.Rickenbacher Bamberg Sym.
Wagner: Cantatas for Chorus Orchestra: On the Beginning of the New Year(1835); Nicolay- Tsar Nicholas I (1837); Webers Grabe, La Descente de la Courtille etc.
Direct quotes from the National
Enquirer
Wagner interview: "When I was a lad , I served a term as composer boy and courts intern, while polishing the Handel on my big Brass door, I took time, these youthful works to score. Filled with festive fun, frolic, pomp and punch...I did it long before I took Tristan and Isolde out to lunch." Great sound and highly spirited performances. ****

SMILING BRUCKNER!
Wilhem Furtwanger claims:" I Once Had Fun".. Comment Sends Shock Through Muscial World..... Fritz Reiner Doubts Authenticity Of Statement...."ENQUIRER EXCLUSIVE: Furtwangler quote: " I was young once, had some fun too. Long before my Second and Third symphonies, of course. Wrote these rather tune-filled works in the later 19th and very early 20th centuries, used Bruckner as my model. I painted a big smile on his photo with a black magic marker and looked up at it just to remind me that music could be a bit of fun as well."
Marco Polo 8.223645 (Naxos) ****
FURTWANGER:OVT. IN E, op. 3; SYM.#0 In D, SYM. #0 in b (1903 &1908)
Alfred Walter- Slovak St.- nice smooth sound.
To have a listen in genuine Low-Fi sound click here:Holmes:Ireland Symphonic Poem
AUGUSTA HOLMES ORCH. WORKS Marco Polo 8.223449
Based on this CD she would get my vote for best women composer of the 20th Century (she died in 1903!). Franz Liszt style tone poems with some Richard Strauss orchestral gloss. Works
include: Poland- Symphonic Poem, Night and Love, Overture for a Comedy, Symphonic Poem, Andromeda, Ireland Symphonic Poem. This is absolutely first rate stuff! Powerful, lyrical, passionate, and indomitable! DON'T MISS THIS ONE!!!
Samuel Friedmann conducts the Rheinland Philharmonic. Great sounding brass*****
CD Music Reviews Classical CD Music Reviews
Classical Music CDs Latest Releases.
Lowest CD Classical Prices Anywhere!
Also, LPs, Historic Broadway Playbills. Click here to Get there fast!

CLICK HERE TO RETURN TO MUSIC IN THE MAIL HOME PAGE
 

 

Several Reviews Spring 1999
U ready for Guridi, I think.
Unknown Janacek worth knowing.
The Unknown Janacek Vol.1 and Vol. 2
Supra. 111878-2 Vol. 1 various artists
Supra. 3129-2 Vol. 2 Brno Phil. cond Leos Svarovsky
Both volumes contain interesting works. Our focus is on
volume two which contains the delightful 54 min. ballet
Rakos Rakoczy (Dances from Valassko) which features a
chorus and sounds like a Czech version of Carmina Burana.
-------------------------------------------------

MORE reviews:

 
 
 
Meyerbeer Heaven, Twice!
CPO Meyerbeer Series Incidental Music
CPO 999 336-2 Jurowski cond Meyerbeer:Struensee,
Les Patineurs, L'Africaine Parts of the incidental
music to Struensee are in the dramatic tradition of
Beethoven's:Egmont. Stirring male chorus and solos and
appropriate military orchestral sounds -- other sections
could be in a ballet. 52 min. The disc concludes with
dramatic L'Africaine prelude and a routine Les Patineurs.
It seems only in a moment like this (when a work has
been recorded by great conductors of the past), do we
realize how uninspired some recommended performances
of obscure works we might actually be! ***
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CPO Meyerbeer Series Festive Occasions Music
CPO 999 168-2 Meyerbeer:Music for Festive Occasions
Jurowski cond NDR Symphony. These are all CD firsts.
The Fest Overture to the London World Exhibition (1862)
has all the pomp and glory of the entire British Empire!
The 16 min work concludes with furious variants on the
British national anthem.Festmarsch (1859) for Schiller's
Centenary, another knock'em-dead work similar to march
from Le Prophete. The last 41 minutes of the disc are
devoted to 4 Festive works celebrating Prussian
Royal Weddings. ***** Grab it!!!!
 
-------------------------------------------
Babadzhanian Herioc Ballad -aka - Rachmaninoff Piano Concerto #5
Full Kettle of Rare Ketelby
More Amirov
Hip Hop Mendelssohn Scotch
Kola a Go Go Gotovac
Ancient Friend/ New Version
Belly Up to the Bar Boys with Hans J. Salter in : Wichita Town
Hiting the Heights - A Tribute to Alfred Newman film scores: The Prince of Foxes
Sir John Barbirolli in Mercury 'Living Presence' plays Chabrier: March
Vincent: Symphony in D and Dello Joio Air Power ---- Jump for Joy
Dvorak: Armida His Last Opera Complete at Last!
Dvorak :Saint Ludmilla Oratorio and other Czech Music
Hermann Scherchen Conducts Berlioz:Les Troyens
Baroque Opera Composers - works by Gretry and Graun
Stokowski Çonducts BeethovenSym#5 and new of other Stokowski Recordings
Handel:Judas MacCabaeus and other oratorios
Schumann :Rare Symphonic Works and the Four Symphonies
Film Music Hollywood includes- Newman:Gunga Din
Inherited Talent-- Siegfried Wagner: Symphonic Poems and Operas
Best Women Composer of the 20th Century -- Augusta Holmes ( she died in1903 !)

MORE REVIEWS - to check on these last entries on this page (click here)

But you can hear the sound files.
U ready for Guridi, I think.
Unknown Janacek worth knowing.
Babadzhanian Herioc Ballad -aka - Rachmaninoff Piano Concerto #5
Full Kettle of Rare Ketelby
More Amirov
CPO Meyerbeer Series Incidental Music
CPO Meyerbeer Series Festive Occasions Music